Pining for rights: Car-Freshner's $3 car freshener to the left and Balenciaga's $275 key chain to the right. Image credit: Springut Law
Balenciaga sued by car-freshener maker for allegedly copying $3 pine tree design
Posted By a Luxury Daily columnist On In Columns,Editor's Choice,Featured,Industry sectors,Legal and privacy,Opinion | No Comments{"ct":"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","iv":"a3279b21cfe70812fed4b73b3f924480","s":"8169050a2a7a7ac0"}