Research
January 8, 2026
Over 50 percent of American shoppers utilized AI as a resource during the holiday shopping window. Image credit: Bluefish
By Kiran Gill
Paid advertising played a minimal role in shaping what consumers saw in AI-powered shopping recommendations during the 2025 holiday season, according to new research from AI marketing firm Bluefish.
{"ct":"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","iv":"d561b0bdef48b4f2947790ef8c457114","s":"17039386f37bfb73"}
Share your thoughts. Click here