Research
January 8, 2026
Over 50 percent of American shoppers utilized AI as a resource during the holiday shopping window. Image credit: Bluefish
By Kiran Gill
Paid advertising played a minimal role in shaping what consumers saw in AI-powered shopping recommendations during the 2025 holiday season, according to new research from AI marketing firm Bluefish.
{"ct":"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","iv":"dbc268d24d4f898cd951dbaf5dd1900e","s":"256c6c46962f4bd7"}
Share your thoughts. Click here