Research
January 8, 2026
Over 50 percent of American shoppers utilized AI as a resource during the holiday shopping window. Image credit: Bluefish
By Kiran Gill
Paid advertising played a minimal role in shaping what consumers saw in AI-powered shopping recommendations during the 2025 holiday season, according to new research from AI marketing firm Bluefish.
{"ct":"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","iv":"186a1930a0fce67aac69c749db275e55","s":"f3b505692c7304b0"}
Share your thoughts. Click here