Research
January 8, 2026
Over 50 percent of American shoppers utilized AI as a resource during the holiday shopping window. Image credit: Bluefish
By Kiran Gill
Paid advertising played a minimal role in shaping what consumers saw in AI-powered shopping recommendations during the 2025 holiday season, according to new research from AI marketing firm Bluefish.
{"ct":"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","iv":"bc7ed60b09c206fb34f6e5106f64c1e8","s":"10d7701b3c706fd0"}
Share your thoughts. Click here