Research
January 8, 2026
Over 50 percent of American shoppers utilized AI as a resource during the holiday shopping window. Image credit: Bluefish
By Kiran Gill
Paid advertising played a minimal role in shaping what consumers saw in AI-powered shopping recommendations during the 2025 holiday season, according to new research from AI marketing firm Bluefish.
{"ct":"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","iv":"0d1faac73deb8bf84c99dd84e36e6e05","s":"7be3fea211fdffe9"}
Share your thoughts. Click here